When does MCP make sense?

Bill Doerrfeld | September 11, 2025

When does using MCP make sense? My latest for The New Stack cuts through the hype to answer this loaded question head-on.


The general consensus is that MCP is a "force multiplier" for indeterministic workflows, novel integrations, and giving AI coding agents context on the fly.


But for more predictable automation, typical CLI commands or API integrations are going to be more reliable in the long run. Anything else is probably overengineering.


Also, one key best practice: You shouldn't be mapping APIs one-to-one — MCP tools should model user intents and consider natural language.


My piece goes a bit deeper and looks at some emerging MCP server success stories at GitHub, Atlassian, Red Hat, and beyond.


This is definitely an evolving area, but I hope this piece tries to make sense of when it's best to put MCP to use!

Read: When Is MCP Actually Worth It?

Other Blog Posts

By Bill Doerrfeld • October 5, 2026
My latest for LeadDev interviews a Meta engineer who built an agentic system to optimize their capacity planning, leading to real power use savings.
By Bill Doerrfeld • September 30, 2026
I set out expecting to write an article about how every enterprise was jumping on trendy alternative or "neo" clouds. That ended up not being the case.
By Bill Doerrfeld • September 28, 2026
Join the virtual AI Pen-Testing Conference to explore how AI is changing penetration testing, red teaming, and the security testing of AI systems.
By Bill Doerrfeld • September 28, 2026
Counting down to Nordic APIs Summit 2026 in Stockholm, featuring 60+ speakers exploring agentic AI, APIs, MCP, and security.
By Bill Doerrfeld • September 28, 2026
I covered a Yale and GitHub report on LeadDev that explores developer attitudes on climate change and curbing IT waste.
By Bill Doerrfeld • September 15, 2026
Does your agent really need access to every tool call under the sun?
By Bill Doerrfeld • September 8, 2026
I'll be writing a weekly series for The New Stack this fall covering Kubernetes, cloud native, and everything happening on the road to KubeCon in November.
By Bill Doerrfeld • September 1, 2026
I'm teaming up with Dan Barahona and AI Security University to put together the MCP Security Conference, a free half-day virtual event dedicated to MCP security .
By Bill Doerrfeld • August 27, 2026
My latest DirectorPlus edition interviews Shopify's head of engineering, Farhan Thawar, on their unique internal engineering culture.
By Bill Doerrfeld • August 24, 2026
Neoclouds promise cheaper GPUs and AI-optimized infrastructure, but can they really challenge hyperscalers? My feature on InfoWorld explores their advantages, risks, and likely role in AI compute.